"As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. I only recommend products that we have tried!"

Selecting the right spray paint can be a important decision, whether you’re embarking on a DIY project, reviving old furniture, or adding a fresh coat of color to various surfaces. Two prominent contenders in the spray paint arena are Rust-Oleum and Krylon. Both brands offer an array of options, each claiming to deliver superior results. This article dives deep into the Rustoleum Vs Krylon debate, exploring their characteristics, application suitability, and overall effectiveness. You will develop a more distinct comprehension of the ideal spray paint for your particular requirements. Here you go!

rustoleum vs krylon spray paint

Krylon Vs Rustoleum Differences

Rust-Oleum and Krylon are two prominent names in the spray paint market, each with its unique characteristics. Let’s explore the distinct features that set Rust-Oleum and Krylon apart:

DurabilityKnown for superior rust protection.
Ideal for metal surfaces prone to corrosion.
Offers long-lasting results with the 2X Ultra Cover series.
Versatile, excelling in artistic applications.
May not provide the same level of rust protection.
Preferred for its ability to cater to various surfaces.
CostGenerally priced competitively for quality and durability.
Investment often pays off with enduring protection.
Often considered budget-friendly.
Popular among cost-conscious consumers and DIY projects.
CoverageSuitable for various surfaces, even under challenging conditions.
Renowned for exceptional even coverage and adherence.
Offers reliable coverage, especially on plastic surfaces.
Known for seamless bonding with plastic materials.
Dry TimeMay require slightly longer drying time.
Durable and lasting finish.
Features quick-drying formulas without compromising quality.
Advantageous for projects demanding efficiency.
Color SelectionVast array of shades, catering to diverse design visions.
Perfect for projects requiring specific or unique colors.
Matches Rust-Oleum’s color diversity.
Valuable for projects where color plays a vital role.

When considering the choice between Krylon and Rust-Oleum spray paints, it’s key to know the distinctions between these two brands. One individual’s experience suggests a preference for Krylon, noting that it yields more favorable results. Conversely, they’ve encountered challenges when layering Rust-Oleum paint, speculating that this might be due to fish oil inclusion in Rust-Oleum’s formulation. This observation hints at potential compatibility issues between Rust-Oleum and other paints.

Jalopy Journal

What Is Rust-Oleum?

Rustoleum stop existing rust

Rust-Oleum is a respected name in coatings and paints. This distinguished brand has established its prominence through a wide array of spray paint products. With an emphasis on innovation and quality, Rustoleum provides a wide selection of products that meet both functional and aesthetic paint needs. Rust-Oleum is defined by its focus on rust prevention, making it a top choice for consumers seeking rust protection. This brand is well-known for its vibrant color range, which allows customers to protect surfaces while expressing their creativity. You can purchase Rust-Oleum at Home Depot Or Lowe’s.

Useful Resource: Wondering if Dollar General sells spray Rust-Oleum Or Krylon paint? Find out in this informative article.


1. Versatility:

Rust-Oleum Spray Paint is a versatile solution designed to adhere to an extensive range of surfaces, making it suitable for a multitude of materials. Whether you’re working with metal, plastic, wood, rims/wheels, or even automotive surfaces, Rust-Oleum offers a reliable coating that ensures both decorative enhancement and protective coverage. From faded furniture to safeguarding car exteriors, this paint adapts effortlessly.

2. Durability:

Renowned for their quality, Rust-Oleum spray paints excel at durability. Their Protective Enamel Spray Paint, in particular, acts as outdoor armor, delivering exceptional resistance to scratches and weathering. This level of durability significantly prolongs colors’ vibrancy and prevents rust, making it a top choice for projects subjected to harsh conditions.

3. Varied Sizes, Colors, and Finishes:

To meet individual preferences, Rust-Oleum offers a diverse selection of spray paint options. These paints come in various sizes, ranging from compact 12 oz cans to larger containers, accommodating projects of all scales. The color spectrum is equally comprehensive, providing a wide array of shades to suit every creative vision. Additionally, the choice of finishes, from glossy to satin and flat, ensures the right aesthetic for any project.

4. Moderate Drying Time:

Rust-Oleum spray paint colors boasts rapid drying times compared to many other brands, it’s important to note that it still requires patience. Within two to four hours, the paint is touch-dry, and after five to nine hours, it becomes handleable. For full curing and reapplication, a minimum of 24 hours is recommended. This drying time balances efficiency and quality.

What is Rust-Oleum used for?

Rust-Oleum covers various surfaces such as metal, concrete, plastic, wood, laminate furniture, wicker, shutters and glass window. While suitable for outdoor protection of items like cars, mailboxes, and fences, it requires proper application on wood. For wooden surfaces, ensure flatness, sand the gritty top layer, and use an oil-based primer for improved adhesion.


  • Rust-Oleum Spray Paint delivers exceptional coverage, often requiring fewer coats than its competitors. This feature not only speeds up the painting process but also ensures a smooth and consistent finish that enhances the visual appeal of the final product.
  • Rust-Oleum offers options. From Rust-Oleum 2X Ultra Cover for quick and efficient projects to Rust-Oleum Protective Enamel, there’s a paint to suit every need. The variety of colors and finishes ensures endless creative possibilities.
  • Rust-Oleum Spray Paint’s unmatched durability makes it an excellent choice for various applications, including automotive projects. Its ability to withstand tough conditions, resist corrosion, and prevent peeling ensures a long-lasting and pristine appearance.


  • Rust-Oleum Spray Paint dries faster than some alternatives, but its curing time might require patience, especially for projects that require speed. Waiting for full drying before reapplication can extend project timelines.
  • Rust-Oleum Protective Enamel offers exceptional durability, but Rust-Oleum 2X may not. It’s important to weigh your project’s needs against the specific paint line to ensure optimal results.

How to Thin Rustoleum Paint for a Spray Gun?

Thinning Rust-Oleum paint for spraying is a simple process that ensures smooth application. Here’s an easy-to-follow guide using acetone as the thinner:

Step 1: Mix the Paint
Start by stirring the Rust-Oleum paint well to evenly distribute the pigments. Pour the separated liquid into a clean container, mix the remaining paint, and return the liquid gradually until you get a consistent texture.

Step 2: Transfer to a Bucket
Put the mixed paint into a large bucket, leaving space for the thinning agent.

Step 3: Add Acetone (Or you can also use Mineral spirit for thinning Rust-Oleum)
Measure 6.5 ounces of acetone per gallon of paint using a measuring cup. Pour the acetone into the paint in the bucket.

Step 4: Mix Well
Stir the acetone and paint thoroughly in the bucket with a stick or dowel until you achieve a smooth mixture.

Step 5: Test the Thinned Paint
Test the paint on a scrap surface or use a funnel to check its thickness. You can also use a viscometer for a precise measurement.

Step 6: Adjust if Needed
If the test shows uneven coverage, add more acetone. If the paint runs, add more paint until you get the right consistency.

Step 7: Load the Sprayer
Once satisfied, use a funnel to pour the thinned Rust-Oleum paint into the paint sprayer. Follow the sprayer instructions for the best results and safety.

Safety Tip:
Always wear protective eyewear and a face mask when working with chemicals like acetone. Maintain a safe distance while spraying.

Following these steps ensures that your Rust-Oleum paint is appropriately thinned for spraying, giving your projects a smooth and professional finish.

What Is Krylon?

Krylon better for plastic

Krylon, a prominent spray paint brand, is cherished for its versatility and artistic finesse. Similarly, Krylon offers an array of spray paints that effectively address the needs of both DIY experts and artists. The brand’s reputation rests on its quick-drying formulas and an impressive array of finishes, ranging from matte to glossy. Krylon’s ability to seamlessly bond to plastic surfaces makes it a preferred choice for plastic projects including painting plastic football helmets.


1. Variety of Colors and Finishes

Krylon spray paint boasts an extensive palette of colors and finishes, ensuring you can match your project to any style or setting. Whether you’re aiming for a glossy sheen, a chalky white, or even a sparkling shimmer, Krylon’s selection covers all bases. The color chart on their official website makes color selection easy.

2. Quick-Drying Formula

Krylon’s standout feature is its rapid-drying capability. Unlike some other brands, Krylon acrylic-based spray paints dry within minutes, allowing you to move on with your project without prolonged waiting times. This attribute puts Krylon ahead, especially when compared to its competitors, offering both efficiency and convenience.

3. Smooth and Even Application

Krylon spray cans are designed for user-friendly application. They have specially designed nozzles for even coverage. Whether you’re a seasoned DIYers or a beginner, Krylon spray paints facilitate precise and uniform application, resulting in a professional-looking outcome.

4. Durability and Protection

Krylon spray paints provide durability and protection. The Fusion line, in particular, offers impressive durability when paired with a BIN shellac primer. This pairing ensures a lasting finish but also enhances the paint’s adhesion to the surface. This contributes to your project’s durability.

5. Sensitive to the Environment

It’s important to note that Krylon spray paint is sensitive to its environment. To achieve the most effective results, users should be mindful of humidity and temperature conditions during application. Proper ambiance plays a crucial role in excellent adhesion and quality finish.

What is Krylon Used For?

Krylon Fusion for Plastic offers versatile adhesion, extending beyond spray painting plastic. It effectively coats wood, metal, hard vinyl, wicker, glass, plaster, wrought iron, and ceramic surfaces. It’s a versatile option for various items, including appliances like refrigerators and microwaves. It protects against moisture and damage to materials such as fiberglass, cement, and acrylic.


  • Krylon’s extensive collection of colors and finishes provides ample options for every project.
  • The quick-drying formula allows for efficient and timely project completion.
  • Krylon’s unique nozzles facilitate smooth and even application, making it accessible for users of all skill levels.
  • Certain lines, like Fusion, offer exceptional durability and protection when paired with suitable primers.


  • The Fusion line might not provide as comprehensive coverage as some other options, necessitating additional coats for full opacity.
  • Color Maxx offers attractive finishes, but its durability might not be as good as some other brands, especially when used with primers like BIN shellac.

rust oleum mirror effect vs krylon looking glass

Krylon vs rustoleum mirror spray paint for glass

Here’s how Krylon’s Looking Glass spray paint compares to Rust-Oleum Mirror Effect spray paint:

I tried both Krylon and Rust-Oleum mirror spray paints on glass. First, I cleaned the glass with a cloth and glass cleaner. Then, I followed the directions: I shook the cans, sprayed from 8-10 inches away, and applied five light coats with a minute between each. Here’s what I found:

Krylon Looking Glass: After applying the paint, I noticed a fine crackle effect that was even all over the glass. It gave the glass an antique appearance. The room temperature at the time was 78°F with 65% humidity. The glass didn’t show many ripples, and the crackling effect covered the surface nicely. The glass ended up looking old, which could be appealing if you’re looking for that style.

Rust-Oleum Mirror Effect: With this paint, there were streaks on the glass that made it look like I didn’t clean it well. Some areas had ripple effects, like glass imperfections. The glass temperature was the same as when I used Krylon paint. The ripple effect was less noticeable here than Krylon, but streakiness was a downside. The mirror looked dull and unpleasant.

Overall, both paints have their pros and cons. Krylon’s paint had a consistent crackle effect that made the glass look old, while Rust-Oleum’s paint had streaks and rippling. The choice depends on the look you want – antique crackling with Krylon or a more reflective surface with Rust-Oleum. In my experience, neither gave a super shiny result, which might disappoint some users.

Is krylon similar to rustoleum?

Krylon vs rustoleum paint-Which is better

Krylon and Rustoleum are comparable in terms of use, price, and versatility. While they both claim to work well without a primer, superior results with a strong bonding primer is recommended. They offer a wide color range and various finishes like gloss, metallic, and matte. Both brands can be applied indoors or outdoors, on diverse surfaces, not limited to just metal. Their shared features include rust prevention and ease of application via spraying.

Krylon fusion vs Rust-oleum 2x for plastic

Krylon Fusion All-In-One boasts 5X Stronger Adhesion, making it ideal for plastic and ready-to-assemble furniture without sanding or priming. It ensures a durable bond, resisting chipping and fading.

rustoleum 2x for plastic

Rust-Oleum Universal offers a versatile, high-quality finish on any surface, with the added convenience of paint and primer in one, and 360-degree spray capability. Rust-Oleum 2X Ultra Cover provides efficient coverage, useful for plastic, wood, ceramic, and metal.

Both options have their strengths: Krylon Fusion excels at adhesion, while Rust-Oleum focuses on universal use and superior coverage. Choose based on your project’s requirements for adhesion and coverage.

Krylon fusion vs colormaxx

krylon vs rustoleum durability

Krylon Fusion offers unparalleled adhesion and rust protection, excelling on plastic, wood, metal, and more, with no need for sanding or priming. It’s ideal for both indoor and outdoor use, with a sleek satin black finish.

In contrast, Krylon ColorMaxx combines primer and spray paint for superior coverage on surfaces like wood, metal, plastic, and glass. It provides gloss white and black options, suitable for various projects. Color Maxx also dries quickly and offers rust protection. Both brands, rooted in Krylon’s trusted legacy since 1947, provide a wide color range. Choosing between them depends on the surface type and desired finish.

FAQS On krylon Over Rustoleum

Can I spray Rustoleum over Krylon paint?

Yes, you can generally spray Rustoleum over Krylon paint, but it’s recommended to ensure proper surface preparation and compatibility to achieve the best results.

Which is better: Krylon or Rustoleum?

Selecting between Krylon and Rust-Oleum depends on the requirements of your project. Rust-Oleum shines in rust prevention, while Krylon Fusion excels in plastic bonding.

Is Krylon or Rust-Oleum better for plastic?

Krylon is better suited for plastic surfaces due to its ability to bond seamlessly with plastic materials, making it a preferred choice for plastic projects.

What paint is comparable to Rust-Oleum?

Duplicolor and Krylon are brands comparable to Rust-Oleum, offering a range of spray paint options for various applications.

Will Krylon stick to metal?

Indeed, Krylon spray paint can bond to metal with proper preparation and technique. Krylon K02732007 Fusion Spray Paint is a convenient option, combining paint and primer for smooth application to metal surfaces.

Does Rustoleum stop existing rust?

Yes, Rustoleum offers products designed to stop and prevent further rust formation. Their rust reformer and primers are formulated to encapsulate existing rust and provide a protective barrier.

Who makes Krylon paint?

Krylon paint is manufactured by the Sherwin-Williams Company, a well-known brand for manufacturing paints and coatings.

Who makes Rustoleum paint?

Rust-Oleum paint is produced by Rust-Oleum Corporation, a company specializing in paint-related materials.

Rosalie Sanchez-Holapaints writer and owner

Rosalie Sanchez

DIY enthusiast with years of experience in home decor and home improvement. With a passion for educating consumers about DIY projects. Every time, I work with our painting professionals to provide you with the best painting product reviews and how-to advice. You can follow me on Facebook.

Similar Posts